« A DNC Memo On McCain | Main | The Daily Five: Just Super »

Who Is John McCain?

28 Mar 2008 04:07 pm

We know what we know.

But next week, his campaign hopes that you will find out a lot of things you don't know... how the story of this Scots-Irish politician is the story of America.

Monday, McCain talks family history at the Naval Air Station north of Meridian, MS. Tuesday, he'll speak about education and his educational influences in Alexandria, VA. Wednesday is the major speech: he'll talk about service-to-country and partiotism at the Naval Academy and then, later in the day, in the cradle of Navy aviation in Pensacola, Fl. Thursday is Jacksonville, which is actually a very Navy town... he celebrates MLK day on Friday and then wraps up the tour in Prescott, Arizona on the very same spot where Barry Goldwater touched off his 1964 presidential campaign.

Share This

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://marcambinder.theatlantic.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/20312

Comments (19)

Isn't MLK day in January?


April 4th is the day MLK Jr. was assassinated. MLK Day was on January 21st.

Note: McCain voted against MLK Day in 1983.

McCain voted against MLK day? You've got to be kidding. I didn't know that.

Because the Goldwater campaign went so well.

Thanks, Colin. I did not know that.

Regarding McCain's tour, may I suggest a soundbite:

"I'm John McCain, and I'm reporting for duty."

We know that one is a winner!

Marc, no one is "celebrating" the anniversary of April 4, 1968. Perhaps you meant commemorating.

He did indeed....here's an article that mentions it (although I don't think its been brought up since 2000):

http://archive.salon.com/politics2000/feature/2000/04/18/mccain/index.html

McCain has since acknowledged that voting against MLK day was wrong and now fully supports it.

I guess at the time he probably thought there were thousands of other honorable Americans who did amazing things but didn't get their own "day".

I think looking back though its clear just how important MLK was.

I guess at the time he probably thought there were thousands of other honorable Americans who did amazing things but didn't get their own "day".

...or maybe he ws voting in lock-step with the right-wing, as usual.

Jesse -- It was very clear in 1983, as well.

Arizona instituted MLK day in 1992.

Ben:
And AZ only approved it because the NFL was going to pull the Super Bowl from Temple over it. Also, doesn't that phony maverick realize that Goldwater got his ass kicked like a rented mule back in '64? Another senior moment obviously.

then wraps up the tour in Prescott, Arizona on the very same spot where Barry Goldwater touched off his 1964 presidential campaign.

Because that went well.

"...how the story of this Scots-Irish politician is the story of America."

When will the Republicans get the fact that John McCain/GW Bush are NOT the story of America? The story of American is much more nuanced and complicated than what they want to project. I mean really, McCain is part of a prestigious military family, went to a military academy, married an heiress, and has never had a real job outside of the military and politics. This is America?

The Republicans and their candidate is fantasy America; a right wingers' dream of America. It's the hot air of values, honor, patriotism, and victory. But in reality it's turned into corruption, war-mongering, nationalism, racism, and a lack of compassion for others outside their socio-economic class.

Will they ever get it? We've had eight years of this crap and now they're peddling another "story of America?"

The Goldwater event should remind everyone that John McCain isn't the first senator from Arizona to run for president on the promise that he will be the one who will blow up the world quickest.

I think the a 21st Century Daisy Ad, highlighting both McCain's warmongering (Bomb Iran, 100 year commitment) and his uncontrolled temper tantrums (cursing out fellow senators), would be great in demonstrating to the country why we can't have a hothead with a hair trigger in the Oval Office.

Um, Jimmy's brother, did you actually listen to McCain's speech on foreign policy last week, or do you just repeat talking points from Salon.com?

I'm not supporting McCain, but I do think it was an interesting move away from unilateralism, and in line with McCain's overall view of foreign policy over the years.

As well, can you can the suggestion that he wants to continue war for 100 years in Iraq? That's a cheap shot if you actually listen to what he said. He said "presence" as, and he gave a specific example, in South Korea. Not "war for another 100 years."

I'm embarrassed when my fellow liberals and fellow Democrats act just like certain Republicans by taking quotes out of context and repeating them ad nauseum.

This is an essential question. We can always hope McCain will address his fundamental weakness on national security and foreign policy as TPM and Acropolis Review have highlighted: http://acropolisreview.com/2008/03/john-mccains-iraq-war-five-year.html

http://talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/184135.php

I'm pretty sure there are 10x as many black people in the US as Scots-Irish and 3x as many Asian-Americans as Scots-Irish. So John McCain's background is the story of John McCain, not America. There's nothing wrong with that but more people have Barack Obama's life story then have a father and grandfather who were Admirals.

John McCain is a lot of things, many of them good, but the American Everyman he ain't.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racial_demographics_of_the_United_States

I'm pretty sure there are 10x as many black people in the US as Scots-Irish and 3x as many Asian-Americans as Scots-Irish.
McCain is only Scots Irish in his patrilineal descent, otherwise, like most Americans his ancestors come from various European countries. (http://www.wargs.com/political/mccain.html)

The comparable category to those you mention would be European-American, of whom (as per your own wiki link) there are roughly six times as many as African-Americans, and eighteen times as many as Asian-Americans.

McCain's immediate family history may not make him an American everyman, but his ethnic origins are as common as could be.

Post a comment

By using this service you agree not to post material that is obscene, harassing, defamatory, or otherwise objectionable. Although The Atlantic does not monitor comments posted to this site (and has no obligation to), it reserves the right to delete, edit, or move any material that it deems to be in violation of this rule.


Copyright © 2007 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.