« Warren Forum: "No Gotcha Questions" | Main | Biden To Georgia »

Thoughts On Rick Warren's Forum

16 Aug 2008 09:23 pm

Who says John McCain fares poorly in these types of sessions? At Rick Warren's forum, he seemed more comfortable and his answers flowed a bit more naturally than Barack Obama's. Granted, the audience was probably more favorably inclined to him. Obama did fine. Penty of humility. And his answer on taxes was as crisp as I've heard.

** Obama got a big standing O. And about half the evangelical crowd seemed to support civil unions.   Reader J: "where did u get that half the audience applauded for civil unions?
there was applause but i dont know that it was from anyone other than the 100 folks obama gave tickets to..."

**  McCain recounted the story of his secretly Christian gun guard who drew a cross with his foot. He teared up as he recalled it. It's a very effective way of talking about what his faith means to him without having to define his theology directly.

** McCain said he would support a federal marriage amendment to the constitution if and when a federal court overturned a state ban on gay marriage. I think that's new, but his campaign disputes this.  (After the jump, the evidence that they sent to me.)

** Three Americans whose advise would be indispensable to McCain: Gen. Petraeus. Rep. John Lewis. And Meg Whitman. (trial balloon?) Obama said he's listen to Dick Lugar and Sam Nunn.
Here's what Sen. John McCain said in 2004 about a federal marriage amendment:

If the Supreme Court of the United States rejects the Defense of Marriage Act as unconstitutional; if state legislatures are frustrated by the decisions of jurists in more states than one, and if state remedies to such judicial activism fail; and finally, if a large majority of Americans come to perceive that their communities' values are being ignored and other standards concerning marriage are being imposed on them against their will, and that elections and state legislatures can provide no remedy then, and only then, should we consider, quite appropriately, amending the Constitution.

And in 2006 on Meet the Press:

My position has always been that I will vote against a constitutional amendment, which will come before the Senate on, on this issue, because I think the states should decide. That's the essence of federalism. In my state of Arizona, we have a ballot initiative on this issue, which I am supporting. And so--but if the courts, if the, if through the court process, they say that that's not constitutional, then I would support a constitutional amendment.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://marcambinder.theatlantic.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/27311

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Thoughts On Rick Warren's Forum:

» Did McCain Best Obama At The Faith Forum? from The Moderate Voice
So how did presumptive party nominees Democratic Sen. Barack Obama and Republican Sen. John McCain fare at Rick Warren’s Saddleback Church faith forum? The answer is in the eye — and active political agenda — of the beholder but ther... [Read More]